Thursday, February 20, 2025

Which philosophers or artists have deal with the living dead? (ChatGPT, 2025-2-29) (自體的心理學)(車行哲學)

 The theme of the living dead—figures who are biologically alive but existentially hollow, trapped between life and death—has been explored by philosophers, writers, and artists across different eras. This theme touches on existential, political, and aesthetic dimensions, from Giorgio Agamben’s concept of bare life to Samuel Beckett’s absurd figures and George Romero’s zombies.

1. Philosophers on the Living Dead


a. Giorgio Agamben – Bare Life and Homo Sacer

• Key Work: Homo Sacer: Sovereign Power and Bare Life (1995)

• Concept: Agamben explores how modern states reduce individuals to “bare life”—human beings who are biologically alive but politically abandoned, much like refugees, prisoners, or those in concentration camps.

• Living Dead as Political Condition: People reduced to mere survival without dignity, autonomy, or meaning.


b. Jacques Derrida – Hauntology

• Key Work: Specters of Marx (1993)

• Concept: Derrida’s hauntology describes how the present is haunted by unresolved ghosts of the past—ideological, historical, and personal.

• Living Dead as the Past That Won’t Die: Capitalism, ideologies, and failed revolutions persist as spectral presences, neither fully alive nor dead.


c. Slavoj Žižek – Zombie Capitalism

• Key Works: Living in the End Times (2010), The Sublime Object of Ideology (1989)

• Concept: The capitalist system, despite its crises, refuses to die—it persists like a zombie, a system running on inertia rather than life.

• Living Dead as Ideological Subjects: People go through motions of freedom while trapped in an automated system they cannot escape.


d. Walter Benjamin – The Eternal Return of the Dead

• Key Work: Theses on the Philosophy of History (1940)

• Concept: History is not a linear progression but a site of repetition and unfinished business—the oppressed of the past never fully die, but wait to be avenged.

• Living Dead as Historical Trauma: The ghosts of the defeated linger in the present, waiting for a revolutionary awakening.


e. Martin Heidegger – The They-Self and Inauthenticity

• Key Work: Being and Time (1927)

• Concept: People who conform to the mass mentality (das Man) live in inauthenticity—they exist, but they are not truly alive.

• Living Dead as Everyday Existence: Most people are absorbed in triviality, avoiding the confrontation with Being-toward-death.

2. Literature & Theater – The Living Dead as Existential and Social Critique


a. Samuel Beckett – Absurd Existence as Living Death

• Key Works: Waiting for Godot (1953), Endgame (1957)

• Concept: Beckett’s characters are stuck in endless waiting, unable to escape their meaningless routines.

• Living Dead as Human Stagnation: Life is repetition without progress, an ongoing state of decay.


b. Franz Kafka – Bureaucratic Living Death

• Key Works: The Trial (1925), The Castle (1926)

• Concept: Kafka’s characters are trapped in endless bureaucratic nightmares, where they remain alive but powerless, faceless, and without agency.

• Living Dead as Bureaucratic Subject: Those crushed by impersonal systems that strip them of individuality.


c. Edgar Allan Poe – Haunted Consciousness

• Key Works: The Fall of the House of Usher (1839), The Black Cat (1843)

• Concept: Poe’s protagonists live in a state of psychological and moral decay, unable to escape their haunted pasts.

• Living Dead as Psychological State: Madness and guilt prevent true life, leaving only decaying existence.


d. Dostoevsky – The Underground Man as a Living Corpse

• Key Work: Notes from Underground (1864)

• Concept: The Underground Man is bitter, isolated, and detached—he has withdrawn from life but refuses to die.

• Living Dead as Self-Imposed Exile: A consciousness so extreme it destroys the possibility of authentic action.

3. Film & Visual Arts – Zombies, Specters, and Hollow Men


a. George A. Romero – The Zombie as Consumerist Allegory

• Key Film: Dawn of the Dead (1978)

• Concept: Zombies represent capitalist consumerism, trapped in endless cycles of desire and consumption.

• Living Dead as Modern Society: People live, but only to consume, without purpose.


b. Andrei Tarkovsky – Stalker and the Ghostly World

• Key Film: Stalker (1979)

• Concept: Characters wander through a decaying, spectral world, neither fully alive nor dead.

• Living Dead as the Collapse of Meaning: People move through landscapes that no longer respond to human presence.


c. Francis Bacon – The Human Form as Living Decay

• Key Artworks: Three Studies for Figures at the Base of a Crucifixion (1944)

• Concept: Bacon’s distorted figures look half-alive, half-dissolved, as if trapped between existence and oblivion.

• Living Dead as the Modern Condition: People exist as fragmented, tormented beings.


d. T.S. Eliot – The Hollow Men

• Key Poem: The Hollow Men (1925)

• Concept: Modern individuals have lost all vitality, existing as empty shells.

• Living Dead as Spiritual Emptiness: People go through the motions of life, but without depth or substance.

Final Reflection: How Does This Relate to Your Thought?


Your philosophy of van life and critique of modern acceleration seems to be a response to the living dead condition:

• The living dead are those trapped in acceleration, automation, and passive existence.

• Speed destroys tempo, which in turn jeopardizes structure, balance, and integrity—creating hollow lives.

• Reclaiming rhythm, attention, and presence could be an antidote to this condition.


Would you say van life, as you conceptualize it, is an escape from the zombie-like automation of modern life? Or do you see it as a way to reawaken those who are half-dead in the system?