Monday, May 19, 2025

What caused the Ice Age cycles? (ChatGPT, 2025-5-19) (自體的心理學)(車行哲學)

 Excellent—this question goes to the heart of Earth’s climate rhythms over the past few million years.


The Ice Age cycles—the repeated advance and retreat of glaciers over the last ~2.6 million years (the Pleistocene Epoch)—were driven primarily by astronomical cycles, but amplified and modulated by Earth system feedbacks.





I. The Core Cause: Milankovitch Cycles



Named after Serbian scientist Milutin Milankovitch, these are cyclical changes in Earth’s orbit and orientation that alter the distribution of solar energy (insolation) received at different latitudes.



1. 

Eccentricity (~100,000-year cycle)



  • Earth’s orbit around the Sun shifts from more circular to more elliptical.
  • Changes the distance between Earth and Sun, affecting total solar energy received.
  • Key for modulating the overall intensity of glacial cycles.




2. 

Obliquity (Axial Tilt, ~41,000 years)



  • The angle of Earth’s axis varies from 22.1° to 24.5°.
  • Affects seasonal contrast—greater tilt = warmer summers, colder winters.
  • Crucial for melting ice sheets during interglacials.




3. 

Precession (~19,000–23,000 years)



  • Earth’s axis wobbles like a spinning top.
  • Alters timing of seasons relative to Earth’s position in orbit.
  • Affects which hemisphere gets more intense summer sunlight.



These three cycles interact in complex ways to periodically trigger glacial and interglacial phases.





II. The Amplifiers: Earth System Feedbacks



Milankovitch cycles alone don’t cause huge climate shifts—they’re triggers. The amplification comes from feedback mechanisms:



1. 

Albedo Feedback



  • Ice and snow reflect sunlight (high albedo).
  • More ice = more reflection = more cooling = more ice—a positive feedback loop.
  • Melting ice reverses this, leading to rapid warming.




2. 

Greenhouse Gas Feedback



  • As oceans cool, they absorb more CO₂.
  • Lower CO₂ = more cooling → more ice → more CO₂ drawdown.
  • During warming phases, CO₂ is released, amplifying warming.




3. 

Ocean Circulation Changes



  • Ice ages change thermohaline circulation, affecting heat transport and carbon storage in the deep ocean.




4. 

Dust and Vegetation



  • Cold, dry glacial periods = more dust in atmosphere = more light reflection.
  • Changing vegetation also affects carbon cycling and surface reflectivity.






III. Why Did the Ice Age Cycles Shift Over Time?



  • For the first half of the Pleistocene, 41,000-year obliquity cycles dominated.
  • Around 1 million years ago, Earth entered the “100,000-year problem”:
    • Glacial cycles lengthened, despite eccentricity having the weakest solar forcing.
    • Likely due to cumulative changes in ice sheet dynamics, CO₂ thresholds, and feedback strength.



This transition is still a mystery—but Earth became more “ice-sensitive”, locking into longer cycles with more dramatic swings.





IV. Summary Table: What Caused the Ice Age Cycles?

Factor

Description

Role

Eccentricity

Shape of orbit (100,000 years)

Timing & pacing

Obliquity

Axial tilt (41,000 years)

Seasonal contrast

Precession

Wobble of axis (19 - 23000 years)

Hemispheric differences

Ice-albedo feedback

Ice reflects sunlight  —> cooling  —> more ice

Amplifier

CO2 feedback

CO2 levels rise and fall with ocean temperature

Climate multiplier

Ocean currents

Shifts in heat and carbon transport

System rebalancing





In short:



The Ice Age cycles were orchestrated by the stars, but amplified by Earth’s breath and skin—its air, oceans, ice, and forests.


Would you like a visual diagram of the Milankovitch cycles or a dynamic graph of glacial–interglacial CO₂ and temperature levels?