Saturday, November 9, 2024

meme machine (自由）（2025）（車行形上學）

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Meme

Artificial Intelligence, Deepfakes, and Disinformation: A Primer （2022）

https://www.jstor.org/stable/resrep42027

題目： 用 meme machine 來探討共匪暴政下中國封建帝制的超穩定結構

題目：How to use the tool of the Meme machine in cultural studies and critical psychotherapy?


How to use the tool of the Meme machine in cultural studies and critical psychotherapy? (ChatGPT, 2024-11-9)


Using the meme machine in cultural studies and critical psychotherapy offers a novel approach to understanding how ideas, values, and identity are constructed, shared, and internalized in both individual and collective consciousness. Here’s how these fields might leverage the concept:


In Cultural Studies


1. Analyze Cultural Narratives and Symbols

• Memes often reflect popular ideas, stereotypes, and symbols that hold cultural significance. By examining common themes in memes, cultural studies can explore how collective beliefs and values are constructed, disseminated, and redefined.

• Example: Investigating how memes represent gender roles, social norms, or political figures can reveal cultural anxieties, power dynamics, or shifts in public opinion. For example, internet memes about traditional masculinity versus contemporary views of gender can uncover underlying cultural tensions.

2. Map Ideological Influence and Propagation

• Memes are vehicles for ideological content, consciously or unconsciously reinforcing certain worldviews. Analyzing the spread of memes allows cultural scholars to track how ideologies move through society, sometimes evolving into powerful narratives or, conversely, facing resistance.

• Example: Analyzing how communist ideology or capitalist critiques are propagated and modified in memes reveals insights into how these ideas resonate (or clash) with cultural values.

3. Identify Cultural Resistance and Subversion

• Memes can serve as a form of resistance, poking fun at or criticizing established norms, figures, and ideologies. They offer a “safe” way for individuals to subvert authority or resist dominant narratives, especially in repressive environments.

• Example: In authoritarian countries, memes that subtly mock leadership or governmental policies often indicate public discontent, allowing cultural studies to trace forms of soft resistance and dissidence.

4. Study Identity and Community Formation

• Memes create in-groups and out-groups, reinforcing identities and helping people feel connected to a community. By studying meme trends within specific subcultures, cultural studies can gain insights into how people use memes to define their identities and beliefs.

• Example: Memes that reflect niche identities (like political affiliations, fandoms, or activist groups) show how digital communities form and reinforce shared values.


In Critical Psychotherapy


1. Examine Internalized Beliefs and Social Scripts

• Memes can reflect and reinforce social scripts that individuals internalize. In critical psychotherapy, analyzing the memes that clients engage with or relate to can offer insight into the values and beliefs they may have absorbed unconsciously.

• Example: If a client frequently shares or identifies with memes that portray productivity as a measure of worth, this may reveal an internalized belief that could be critically examined in therapy.

2. Use Memes as Reflective Tools

• Memes can be used in therapy to help clients reflect on aspects of their identity or experiences with humor and detachment. For clients who struggle with serious topics, memes can introduce a lighter perspective, helping them explore sensitive issues more openly.

• Example: Clients dealing with burnout might benefit from memes that critique hustle culture, creating space to explore their own relationship with work and productivity in a less confrontational way.

3. Identify and Challenge Societal Influences

• Critical psychotherapy aims to uncover how societal and structural forces shape an individual’s psyche. Memes, as tools of social commentary, can highlight societal pressures or unrealistic standards (e.g., body image, success), which therapists and clients can critically examine together.

• Example: Memes about body image that both conform to and critique societal beauty standards can be used to explore a client’s own beliefs about self-worth and acceptance.

4. Encourage Cultural and Ideological Awareness

• Memes can serve as entry points to discuss how clients’ values may be shaped by cultural and ideological forces beyond their awareness. This awareness can lead to self-empowerment as clients recognize which beliefs are authentically theirs and which were inherited from external sources.

• Example: Memes about “toxic positivity” might be used to discuss with clients the limitations of always appearing positive, opening a path to authenticity and acceptance of a broader emotional range.

5. Develop a Shared Language for Expression

• Memes create a familiar, shared language that can facilitate communication between therapists and clients, especially younger clients. Memes can help clients articulate complex emotions or views in a relatable way, and therapists can use this language to build rapport and mutual understanding.

• Example: Clients who struggle to describe feelings of anxiety or existential uncertainty may find memes depicting these states comforting and validating, allowing therapists to deepen their understanding of the client’s experience.

6. Empower Clients to Reshape Their Narrative

• By engaging with or creating memes, clients can become active participants in shaping their own narratives. This can be particularly empowering in critical psychotherapy, where the goal is to help clients reclaim their voice from societal pressures.

• Example: Encouraging clients to create their own memes reflecting their perspectives on societal expectations or personal struggles could be a therapeutic exercise in asserting their worldview.


Using memes as tools in cultural studies and critical psychotherapy allows for nuanced exploration of how culture shapes beliefs, identities, and mental health. By bringing these often-humorous, sometimes critical representations into scholarly and therapeutic spaces, we gain an accessible and relatable way to unpack complex social and psychological issues.


THE MEME MACHINE (K M WOODWARD, 2024)


The Meme Machine (Susan Blackmore, Richard Dawkins (Foreword), 2000)



Humans are extraordinary creatures, with the unique ability among animals to imitate and so copy from one another ideas, habits, skills, behaviours, inventions, songs, and stories. These are all memes, a term first coined by Richard Dawkins in 1976 in his book The Selfish Gene. Memes, like genes, are replicators, and this enthralling book is an investigation of whether this link between genes and memes can lead to important discoveries about the nature of the inner self. Confronting the deepest questions about our inner selves, with all our emotions, memories, beliefs, and decisions, Susan Blackmore makes a compelling case for the theory that the inner self is merely an illusion created by the memes for the sake of replication.

What is a meme? First coined by Richard Dawkins in The Selfish Gene, a meme is any idea, behavior, or skill that can be transferred from one person to another by imitation: stories, fashions, inventions, recipes, songs, ways of plowing a field or throwing a baseball or making a sculpture. The meme is also one of the most important--and controversial--concepts to emerge since The Origin of the Species appeared nearly 150 years ago.

In The Meme Machine Susan Blackmore boldly asserts: "Just as the design of our bodies can be understood only in terms of natural selection, so the design of our minds can be understood only in terms of memetic selection." Indeed, Blackmore shows that once our distant ancestors acquired the crucial ability to imitate, a second kind of natural selection began, a survival of the fittest amongst competing ideas and behaviors. Ideas and behaviors that proved most adaptive--making tools, for example, or using language--survived and flourished, replicating themselves in as many minds as possible. These memes then passed themselves on from generation to generation by helping to ensure that the genes of those who acquired them also survived and reproduced. Applying this theory to many aspects of human life, Blackmore offers brilliant explanations for why we live in cities, why we talk so much, why we can't stop thinking, why we behave altruistically, how we choose our mates, and much more.

With controversial implications for our religious beliefs, our free will, our very sense of "self," The Meme Machine offers a provocative theory everyone will soon be talking about.

How to use the meme machine to study ideology, especially the communist ideology, and the Chinese feudal system, including the emperor? (ChatGPT, 2024-11-9)


Using memes as a tool for studying ideology, especially complex structures like communist ideology or the Chinese feudal system, requires understanding how memes can distill, critique, or subvert cultural symbols and ideas. Here’s how you can approach this:


1. Analyze Ideological Symbols in Memes


• Communist Ideology: Identify memes that depict symbols of communist ideology, such as the hammer and sickle, workers’ unity, and slogans like “Proletarians of all countries, unite!” Memes often simplify these symbols, making it possible to analyze how they’re perceived and interpreted in modern contexts.

• Chinese Feudal System & Emperor Figures: Explore how the Chinese emperor or feudal hierarchy is represented in memes. This includes studying tropes associated with the emperor’s power, the mandate of heaven, and Confucian concepts of loyalty and hierarchy. Memes may use these figures to comment on authority and power structures that persist in Chinese culture.


2. Trace Historical Continuities and Satire


• Memes often point to continuities between past and present ideologies, such as the connection between communist governance and traditional authoritarianism. Analyzing these connections can reveal how modern Chinese governance is either satirized as “new emperorship” or contrasted with the old imperial system.

• Example: A meme showing a modern Chinese leader with imperial clothing could reveal public sentiment on how the authority of the state is perceived, blending communist ideology with symbols of historical authority.


3. Study Memes as Modern-Day Propaganda or Counter-Propaganda


• Both state-sponsored and grassroots memes can serve as ideological tools. In China, pro-government memes may reinforce nationalism or communist values, while underground or dissident memes might critique these ideologies, using humor as a form of resistance.

• Consider memes as a continuation of propaganda techniques but with a humorous, relatable twist that appeals to younger generations. Investigate how these memes communicate core ideological values or expose contradictions within the ideologies.


4. Explore the Language of Power and Authority


• Memes about communist ideology or the feudal system often play on language associated with power, control, and revolution. Analyzing this language can reveal popular attitudes towards authority and how the public critiques or accepts power structures.

• Example: Compare memes about feudal obedience (loyalty to the emperor) with memes about modern political obedience in a communist state, as they can reveal subtle critiques of power dynamics.


5. Observe Meme Trends and Their Influence on Public Opinion


• Tracking the popularity and themes of memes over time provides insights into how ideologies are evolving in public consciousness. This can be particularly valuable in understanding how the portrayal of communist ideas and feudal symbols shifts in response to political events.


6. Utilize Memes in Educational or Analytical Work


• To study ideology systematically, compile a set of memes related to each topic. Analyze them for recurring themes, symbols, and cultural references. Use this collection to trace patterns in how ideology is interpreted or subverted in digital culture, comparing it to more traditional representations of these ideas.


By examining these aspects, memes can serve as a unique and accessible lens through which to understand, critique, and engage with the narratives, symbols, and transformations of both communist and feudal ideologies in China.


Is the self, which we cherish so much, nothing but the product of the meme machine?  （ChatGPT, 2024-11-9)


This is a fascinating question that touches on a deep intersection between psychology, philosophy, and memetics. The idea that the self might be a product of the “meme machine” suggests that much of what we experience as our identity—our values, beliefs, and even our sense of self—could be shaped by the memes, or cultural units, that propagate through society.


Here are some ways to explore this idea further:


1. The Self as a Collection of Memes


• According to memetics, our beliefs, ideas, and behaviors are often influenced by the cultural “memes” we absorb from our environment. If this is true, much of what we consider our “self” might indeed be a patchwork of these cultural ideas. The stories, values, and identities we cling to may be shaped by what has been culturally advantageous, passed down as “memes” to help us fit into and navigate society.


2. Memes and the Formation of Identity


• From a psychological perspective, the self is constructed through experience and socialization. As we grow, we absorb values and narratives from family, culture, media, and even political ideologies. These are all forms of memes, shaping our values, our judgments, and even our personalities. In this sense, the self could be viewed as the result of a lifetime’s worth of memetic influences.


3. The Illusion of a “True” Self


• Some philosophers and psychologists argue that the self is an illusion—a constantly shifting narrative pieced together by our minds to create coherence. If this is true, then perhaps what we cherish as “our self” is a kind of memetic construct, a story that feels real but is woven from cultural narratives, symbols, and ideas that propagate because they work well in a given social context.


4. Memes, Self-Reflection, and Autonomy


• If the self is, in part, a product of the meme machine, then one could argue that true autonomy involves examining and questioning the memes we’ve internalized. Philosophers from various traditions have suggested that freedom and self-understanding require seeing through these influences to discover what values genuinely resonate. By scrutinizing the memes that have shaped us, we might uncover or construct a self that feels more autonomous.


5. The Existential Question of Self-Made Meaning


• Existentialists like Jean-Paul Sartre and others would argue that even if the self is shaped by memes, individuals have the power to create personal meaning. In this view, acknowledging the influence of memes doesn’t negate the possibility of a self; rather, it challenges us to actively choose which ideas and narratives we embrace as part of our identity.


6. The Self Beyond the Meme Machine?


• While it’s possible the self is largely shaped by memes, there could also be an element of human consciousness or experience that resists total definition by cultural influences—a sort of raw, unconstructed “core” of awareness. This could be what some mystics and philosophers mean by a transcendent or authentic self that exists beyond societal conditioning.


In summary, there’s a compelling case that much of what we consider the self is, in fact, shaped by the meme machine. But this doesn’t necessarily negate the value of the self. It might instead mean that understanding ourselves includes understanding the memes that influence us, giving us the opportunity to be both creators and participants in our own identity.


What’s Susan Blackmore’s further thoughts about the meme machine after her book of 2000? （ChatGPT, 2024-11-9)


Since the publication of “The Meme Machine” in 1999, Susan Blackmore has continued to explore and expand upon the concept of memes and their influence on human behavior and culture. In her 2000 article “The Power of Memes,” she delves into how memes act as replicators, shaping human evolution and cultural development. She emphasizes that from a meme’s perspective, humans function as vehicles for meme propagation, competing for attention and replication. 


In 2002, Blackmore presented “The Evolution of Meme Machines,” where she addressed challenges in the field of memetics, particularly the misuse and misunderstanding of the term “meme” in popular discourse. She reiterated that memes are units of cultural transmission, encompassing behaviors and artifacts that are imitated and replicated. Blackmore also discussed the co-evolution of humans and memes, suggesting that humans have become “meme machines” that facilitate the replication and evolution of memes. 


Throughout her subsequent work, Blackmore has maintained that memes play a crucial role in shaping human culture and consciousness. She continues to explore the implications of memetic theory, including its impact on understanding human behavior, the development of technology, and the evolution of culture.


Posted by at