Monday, May 19, 2025

Where did the water come from on the Earth? (ChatGPT, 2025-5-19) (自體的心理學)(車行哲學)

 Excellent question—one of the most profound mysteries in planetary science.



Where did Earth’s water come from?



The answer is still being refined, but the best current understanding is:


Earth’s water came from a combination of internal and external sources, delivered across deep cosmic time.


Let’s explore the key theories:





I. Internal Origin Theory (from Earth’s interior)




1. 

Degassing of the Mantle



  • When Earth formed ~4.5 billion years ago, it was a hot, molten ball.
  • Water may have been locked in minerals deep inside the mantle.
  • Through volcanic outgassing, steam and water vapor were released into the early atmosphere, which eventually condensed into oceans.



This suggests that Earth was “born wet”—with water as part of its original material.





II. External Origin Theory (delivered from space)




1. 

Asteroids (Carbonaceous Chondrites)



  • Some of Earth’s water likely came from water-rich asteroids early in its history.
  • These asteroids contain hydroxyl and ice locked in minerals.
  • Their isotopic signature (specifically deuterium-to-hydrogen ratio) matches Earth’s ocean water surprisingly well.
  • These may have bombarded Earth during the Late Heavy Bombardment (~4.1–3.8 bya).




2. 

Comets (Less Likely)



  • Comets are ice-rich bodies from the outer solar system.
  • For a long time, they were thought to be Earth’s water source.
  • But many comets have too much deuterium compared to Earth’s oceans.
  • So comets likely contributed only a small fraction of Earth’s water.






III. Most Accepted Current View: A Mixed Origin



Scientists now believe Earth’s water came from a combination:


  • Primordial water from Earth’s accreting materials,
  • Plus supplemental delivery by water-rich asteroids in the early solar system.



In other words:

Earth didn’t inherit a full ocean—but it had the seeds, and the rest arrived in cosmic rain.





IV. Timeline of Earth’s Water

Time (bya)

Event

Water Source

~4.6

Earth forms from solar nebula

Some water in original planetesimals

~4.4

Water locked in minerals, starts outgassing

Volcanic steam creates early atmosphere

~4.1 - 3.8

Late Heavy Bombardment

Asteroids deliver water and volatiles

~4.0

Oceans form - liquid water stable

Earth cools, atmosphere condenses





Why It Matters



  • Water is life’s solvent. No water = no life.
  • Understanding where it came from is to ask:
    Is Earth unique? Or is water (and life) likely elsewhere in the cosmos too?



And the more we study meteorites, comets, and other exoplanets, the more it seems:


Water is not rare. Life’s conditions may be scattered like seeds across the universe.


Would you like a cosmic water origin infographic or a mythopoetic telling—“the arrival of oceans from the stars”?