Wednesday, August 21, 2024

Throughout the philosophical history, which philosopher or school agree with monism? (ChatGPT, 2024-8-21) (存在治療)(1130803)(negativity vs vitality)

Monism has been a central idea in various philosophical traditions throughout history. Here are some of the key philosophers and schools that have embraced monistic views:


### **1. Ancient Indian Philosophy:**

   - **Advaita Vedanta:** This school of Hindu philosophy, primarily associated with the philosopher **Adi Shankaracharya (8th century CE)**, is one of the most well-known proponents of monism. Advaita Vedanta teaches that the ultimate reality, **Brahman**, is the only true existence, and the diversity of the world is an illusion (Maya).


### **2. Pre-Socratic Greek Philosophy:**

   - **Thales of Miletus (c. 624 – c. 546 BCE):** Often considered the first Western philosopher, Thales is believed to have proposed that water is the fundamental substance underlying all things, a form of material monism.

   - **Anaximenes (c. 586 – c. 526 BCE):** Another Pre-Socratic philosopher, who suggested that air is the fundamental substance of the cosmos.

   - **Heraclitus (c. 535 – c. 475 BCE):** Though often associated with the idea of constant change ("everything flows"), Heraclitus also proposed a form of monism, where the underlying reality is the ever-living fire, symbolizing both change and unity.


### **3. Neoplatonism:**

   - **Plotinus (c. 204 – 270 CE):** A major figure in Neoplatonism, Plotinus developed a form of monism based on the concept of "The One," an ultimate, ineffable source of all existence. According to Plotinus, everything emanates from The One, and reality is a hierarchy descending from this singular principle.


### **4. Spinoza:**

   - **Baruch Spinoza (1632 – 1677):** A Dutch philosopher, Spinoza is one of the most prominent modern monists. In his work *Ethics*, Spinoza argued for a form of monism where God and Nature (Deus sive Natura) are the same substance, and everything in existence is a mode of this one substance.


### **5. German Idealism:**

   - **Georg Wilhelm Friedrich Hegel (1770 – 1831):** Hegel proposed a monistic view where reality is the unfolding of the Absolute, a single, dynamic process of self-realization and development. For Hegel, all individual entities are expressions of this Absolute.


### **6. Modern Physics and Philosophy:**

   - **Albert Einstein:** While not a philosopher in the traditional sense, Einstein's views on the nature of reality were influenced by monistic ideas. His belief in the unity of the physical laws and his pursuit of a unified field theory reflect a monistic approach to understanding the universe.

   - **Erwin Schrödinger:** The physicist Schrödinger, known for his contributions to quantum mechanics, also held monistic views, particularly in his philosophical writings where he discussed the idea that consciousness and the universe are fundamentally one.


### **7. Contemporary Philosophy:**

   - **David Bohm:** A physicist and philosopher, Bohm proposed a monistic view in which the universe is an undivided whole, with all apparent separations being illusions. His ideas on the "implicate order" suggest that everything is interconnected at a deeper level of reality.


These philosophers and schools represent a wide range of approaches to monism, from metaphysical to materialistic interpretations. While their specific doctrines differ, they all share the core belief that the diversity of existence can be reduced to or is ultimately derived from a single, underlying reality.